I had a thought on this and want to make sure this isn't what's happening - your scout plays will be cleared after each game, because you new opponent doesn't necessarily have the same playbook and most certainly won't have the same usage of the playbook if it is similar. So you do need to set your scout plays for each game. Are you setting the scout plays and then leaving the page, then coming back to it and they are gone? Or is there a game that is spanning between the times you look at your scouting plays?