That's now. I recall perfectly now. Right when JDB introduced v4.6 and for a time period thereafter he played a game of making poor kicker and QB draft classes; especially in dispersal drafts.
In an attempt to parity the game amongst GMs as we figured out the code - the kickers started missing horrifically. There were definitely a confluence of events propping up defense, funneling the games to all be close.
He course corrected the kicking. I vividly remember kicks going askew from everything, every distance...
even extra points now that I think about it.